For some serious offences, the law requires the accused to “show cause” — that is, to demonstrate to the court why detention is not justified.
Under section 16B of the Bail Act 2013 (NSW), “show cause” offences include (but are not limited to):
- Certain drug supply or importation offences.
- Serious firearms offences.
- Serious violence or sexual offences.
- Offences committed while already on bail or parole.
In these cases, the accused must first show cause before the court will consider the normal bail concerns test.
Examples of reasons that might satisfy the “show cause” requirement include:
- Strong prospects of successfully defending the charge(s) or weak prosecution evidence.
- Delay in the matter being heard.
- Need to care for dependants.
- Health issues that cannot be adequately managed in custody.
If the court is satisfied that cause has been shown, it will then assess bail concerns as in any other application.